You Can See Everything – review

Fielder and Oppenheim’s voyage into truth and performance is like Kiarostami’s Close-Up for the Age of Bullshit. A masterpiece.

★★★★★


The first voice in You Can See Everything is not Elizabeth Holmes’s. It belongs to Billy Evans, her partner and the father of her two children, explaining down a phone line that the couple want her last month before prison put on film. The man who’ll be quizzing them is Nathan Fielder, whose first question is: why?

In the end Fielder, together with co-director Lance Oppenheim (Primetime), shot over three years, starting in 2023 with the weeks Fielder spent living in the family’s rented beach house. Evans twitchily patrols the edges of every interview, hollow-eyed, and ready to shut down any line of questioning he dislikes. A baby sits on the kitchen counter. Holmes, at the centre, has the spaced-out composure of someone who has spent a decade being looked at, and seems to live a long, long way behind her eyes.

Under gentle but firm pressure from Fielder, Holmes tells him she has never lied. Not just about Theranos, but about anything, ever – not even a white lie. This is a claim Fielder clearly regards as preposterous.

In his book On Bullshit Harry Frankfurt distinguished the liar, who has to know the truth in order to hide it, from the bullshitter, who has stopped caring where the truth is. Holmes’s own formula is ‘All I know is my truth’. It may be the most candid thing she says. Modern therapists might tell patients to live their truth, and that may be exactly what Holmes is doing. But is living your truth simply embracing your delusion? Or is it making your own reality?

The tension comes from pitting Holmes, a convicted scammer with the soft reassuring voice and thousand-yard stare of a cult leader, against Fielder, a man whose frustrated insistence on clarity and precision, and muted affect, resemble certain features of autism. What slowly emerges is, among many things, a kind of battle between two forms of neurodivergence, with Fielder trying to find the rational, objective truth of a woman who lives inside her own world. Each doggedly is true to themselves to the point of mutual malfunction.

The first half is punctuated by small, excruciating tests. For the couple, Fielder screens Abbott and Costello’s ‘Who’s on First?’ and Holmes cannot find the joke; asked who is on first, she cannot say, claiming the skit is funny but unable to say why. She holds that her claims that the Theranos machine could ‘do any test’ were never lies, and Fielder holds, flatly, that it could not do them. She sits down with him to watch the television drama made about her and cannot get through it. The gap between another telling of the story and her own reality seems overwhelmingly dissonant.

Evans, meanwhile, showers naked in front of the camera: total transparency, offered as a dare – or a performance of dominance, or an exercise in narcissism. Throughout, Ari Balouzian’s score plays underneath as if for a psychological thriller.

Oppenheim’s lens keeps Holmes in extreme close-up, the famous unblinking eyes filling the frame, and finds nothing behind them it can name. Instead it catches the strain of a person whose account of herself cannot survive contact with the record, and who has withdrawn into a cod-spiritual moral absolutism in which her truth is the only kind there is. Whether she believes it, the film cannot say.

On Nathan for You and The Rehearsal, Fielder’s deadpan style worked as armour. Faced with Holmes, it starts to malfunction. He is sweaty, unsure of himself and often visibly out of his depth, and the film is keen to show that. The scepticism he brings to the couple is earned, as is the cynicism running under the comedy, and the film turns on its director almost as readily as on its subjects.

Holmes reports to prison at around the 90-minute mark, filmed from behind and at a distance. Some directors would wrap up here, just as the beach-house weeks have begun to feel drawn out, and cap it with some speech about unknowability. But not Fielder and Oppenheim. For them, this is when the film turns, and the second movement of this three-hour masterpiece is like nothing you could have expected.


SPOILERS AHEAD – STOP READING IF YOU HAVEN’T SEEN THE FILM


The second half jumps two years, when Amanda Seyfried turns up on Fielder’s couch. She played Elizabeth Holmes in The Dropout, the drama Holmes could not finish watching, and she is here to play her again. With Holmes in prison and the cameras shut out, Fielder writes up transcripts of the exchanges he could not film, and Seyfried performs them opposite him, with Christopher Abbott standing in for Evans.

Fielder restages a meeting, with actors as A24’s executives, at which Evans asked for a share of the film’s profits. Putting the deal on screen turns the obvious objection into material, and adds a further layer of doubt. Evans is now the subject, unnerving in his own right and less and less willing to cooperate. Every part of his self-presentation – boasting about his gun, claiming an ability to visit vengeance on his enemies, a messianic belief in the message of Charlie Kirk – could be a performance for money or the act of a fantasist with delusions of grandeur. The film twists and coils as it attempts to squeeze the truth from his persona.

The nearest ancestor to all this is Close-Up, Abbas Kiarostami’s 1990 film about Hossain Sabzian, the unemployed cinephile who passed himself off as the director Mohsen Makhmalbaf to a family in Tehran. Kiarostami filmed the trial and had everyone involved re-enact the events as themselves, until what Sabzian had wanted could no longer be told apart from what he was performing for the camera. Holmes’s fraud was vastly more consequential, and Fielder is far more present in his film than Kiarostami was in his. But the method and the questions are the same.

Through all this, Seyfried becomes Fielder’s accomplice and, at times, his interrogator. She meets Evans, as herself, in Texas, and he berates her to her face. She asks whether Fielder has grown protective of Holmes, and at one unguarded point, when considering the Holmes-Evans relationship, she gasps ‘I want to break them up!’

When it comes to ethics in documentary filmmaking, You Can See Everything certainly gives its audience a lot to chew on. Everyone is using everyone. Holmes and Evans wanted a rehabilitation, Fielder and Oppenheim wanted a film, and Seyfried gets to audit her own performance against the woman it was based on. The film is sceptical of all of it, with good reason, and puts its own conduct up for inspection alongside theirs. Holmes failing to sit through The Dropout due to its lack of fidelity primes the audience: by the time Seyfried arrives, viewers are ready to interrogate every reconstruction they are shown.

Of course, you can’t see everything. You can’t see what Holmes and Evans keep inside them. You can’t see whatever was left on the cutting room floor. There are no patients who were given false results, no former employees, no voices from outside the household beyond the people making the film. But the title is pointedly ironic. Holmes and Evans offer total access as a strategy; the film offers total vision as a premise it knows to be false.

In particular, a reference to a rape – raised by one of the people on camera, interrupted by Evans and then dropped by the film – suggests that total knowledge of its subject may not just be impossible, but improper. Perhaps we not only cannot know everything about each other, but should not. By the end Holmes and Evans seem to have formed a psychological dyad, with Holmes somehow incomplete without him, even as he assumes control of her affairs and posts as her on X (formerly Twitter), abandoning her beatific nature and telling critics to Fuck Off.

Whether Fielder has been bamboozled is left open. Kiarostami ended Close-Up with Sabzian riding pillion on Makhmalbaf’s motorbike, the sound cutting in and out so that most of what passes between them is lost. You Can See Everything closes on Fielder and Holmes swimming, out in the choppy waters where the microphones cannot reach. You can see them, but you’ll never understand.


You Can See Everything is in US, UK and Irish cinemas now.

Leave a Reply